By Amy Chaplin
Music Learning Theory—have you heard of it? Music Learning Theory, or MLT for short, is an explanation developed by Dr. Edwin Gordon of how we learn when we learn music. While the depth of research is extensive, MLT can be summed up in one word, coined by Dr. Gordon himself: audiate.
Still fairly new to the music world, the term combines the prefix “aud,” which pertains to sound or hearing, and the verb “ideate,” which means to form an idea or to think. Thus the term audiate means thinking in musical sound.
Since audiation is the foundation of and most important ingredient to Music Learning Theory, I thought it was a great place to start.
Audiation vs. Inner Hearing vs. Imitation
What’s so special about the term audiation? There’s a good chance you’re thinking to yourself, “I hear musical sound in my head, so I’m audiating, right?” Well, not quite. Audiation is the ability to hear and think music with understanding.
To help you understand what audiation truly is, I’m going to need a little active participation from you.
Let’s consider a simple tune we all know: “Hot Cross Buns.”
Now, close your eyes and think through that song in your head.
Finished? What we just did is called “inner hearing.” You’re recalling sounds that are not currently present, imitating the sound of something (in this case) that you already know.
There’s no difference in imitation and inner hearing. We can imitate anything without really understanding. I could hear someone speak a phrase in a foreign language, recall it silently in my head, and repeat it back to them but have no clue what it means or how to converse in that language.
While imitation is a crucial step in developing audiation, it’s only the beginning. Audiation takes our inner hearing one step further and gives us a process for organizing what we hear coherently. Adding context gives the sound meaning and allows us to hear musical sound with comprehension.
“We’re always imitating. We’re not always audiating.”—Dr. Gordon
Consider our tune “Hot Cross Buns” again.
When we are truly audiating, we recognize several things:
- It’s in duple meter (the big pulse is divided into two).
- There are only two rhythm patterns in the whole song. Measures 1, 2, and 4 are the same and measure 3 is different.
- It’s in major tonality because the resting tone is “Do.”
- The melody does not start on the resting tone, but it does end on the resting tone. It starts on the 3rd scale degree, or “Mi.”
- The harmony sits on tonic until the last phrase when it moves to the dominant on the words “two-a-penny,” then moves back to rest on “Do.”
Unfortunately, a large chunk of my musical life passed by without me ever thinking music in this way.
Thirteen years ago, when I first started playing from chord charts on my church’s worship team, I remember having to have the bass guitarist whisper to me when the chords were changing because I COULDN’T HEAR IT—and I got an “A” in ear training in college!
What’s wrong with this picture? Do you relate?
After all these years, I’m finally at the place where I’m starting to hear music with understanding but I still have a long way to go.
I’m confident this is why I struggled so much with memorization and performance anxiety my whole life. I relied so much only on muscle memory and my literal memory of individual scales and patterns and notes that I had no viable way to recover because I was not actually audiating the music, just recalling.
Memory and recognition, like imitation, while a part of the audiation process, but are not audiation. I’m sure there are many students and even musicians out there like me who memorize music without audiating contextually.
“Recognition and recall can occur without the accuracy and comprehension audiation provides. Of course, it is possible to audiate memorized music.” —Dr. Gordon
In case you’re wondering, audiation of notation is called notational audiation.
The Foundation of Audiation
Audiation can take place at different times—when music is present, has been present, or was never present.
The latter is where creativity and improvisation come in. To develop that audiation “sense” of music that informs and helps us predict what will happen next or create music that was not present, we have to have built our music vocabulary (and I don’t mean music terms and symbols).
Audiation is the foundation for MLT; rhythm and tonal patterns are the foundation of audiation.
Once again, let’s refer to our tune “Hot Cross Buns.”
When you thought through the song, you most likely were able to think it in a fraction of the time that it would take for you to sing or play in real time.
That’s because, just as we think and read words in a language and not the letters of the alphabet when we think sound, we don’t think through every single pitch, just essential pitches, and durations. We audiate and read patterns in music, not individual notes and rhythms.
A rhythm pattern would be such as we stated earlier. Hot Cross Buns has only two rhythm patterns. The pattern on lines 1, 2, 4, and the pattern on line 3.
Tonal patterns are based on the harmonic functions that ground us in that tonality. For major keys, that would be the major I, IV, and V. If I were presenting Hot Cross Buns to a student, I might have them sing the I (Do-Mi-So) in varying orders and the V (So-Fa-Re-Ti) or a selection of those pitches in varying orders to cement the major tonality in their ears.
How Can We Foster Audiation?
There are four ways you can begin to create opportunities for yourself and your students to develop your audiation—or musical “sense.”
- Develop a sense of the resting tone. Be able to sing the resting tone at any moment in a piece. MLT uses La-based minor, so if the resting tone is “Do” we are in major tonality. If the resting tone is “La” then we are in harmonic minor tonality (with a raised Si, of course; otherwise it’s Aeolian tonality.) There are eight tonalities (seven scale degrees plus harmonic minor), so don’t relegate yourself or your students to only hearing major and minor tonalities. Many might argue that since music of our Western culture is mostly major or minor, that’s where we should focus. It’s quite the opposite. We learn by contrasts. We learn what things are by what they are not. To develop your best sense of major and minor tonalities, we need exposure to other tonalities – to something that it is not. Consider these ideas: give students pieces in other tonalities, set up “audiation station” listening labs, or conduct singing and movement activities during group classes. Introduce tunes in varying meters and tonalities whenever possible.
- State what meter you hear in any piece of music. All music, as MLT addresses, can be boiled down to this: is the big beat divided into two (duple meter – 2/4, 4/4, 2/2, etc.) or is the big beat divided into three (triple meter – 3/4, 6/8, 9/8, 6/4, etc.)? Work towards being able to quickly identify and state the meter of any piece of music you hear.
- Think of and present music to students as series of rhythm and tonal patterns. MLT uses a whole-part-whole approach. Present a piece, pull it apart using rhythm and tonal pattern instruction (have students echo patterns), then bring it back together as a whole.
- Focus on harmonic functions through the bass harmony. Using simple, familiar earpieces like Hot Cross Buns, Row, Row, Row Your Boat, and others like these are excellent tools for building these skills. Help your students listen for the changing harmonies in the bass, and use this as a point of discussion for how chords should function and how to hear the harmony in music.
Giving the Gift of Music
I am so thankful that I walked into the world of Music Learning Theory! For years I looked at myself and was always frustrated and embarrassed by my inability to play by ear or improvise. I would look at other musicians that could hear and play at the drop of a hat and there I was with 20 years of piano lessons and a 4-year degree in music, and I had no clue.
Of course, I could play any piece of music put in front of me – an important skill for which I am thankful. That being said, I don’t want my students to be like me and grow up cowering in public when someone looks at them and says “hey, you take piano lessons, play something.” I hope that I can give my students the gift of a musical “sense” from the start so they can be active participants in making and conversing through music.
An avid learner, teacher, presenter, and writer, Amy Chaplin shares her passions at PianoPantry.com. She holds a Masters in piano pedagogy and performance, operates Studio 88, an independent piano studio in Bluffton, Indiana, and serves as President for Indiana MTA.